
Sweet Nelly's Pre Orders
NOTE! You must set a time for pick-up, you may have to adjust times. We require at least five days of notice for many items; please take note of timing.

Cookies
Our bakery cookies are freshly baked in small batches using real butter and quality ingredients. Soft, flavorful, and thoughtfully made, each cookie offers a cozy, nostalgic sweetness that’s perfect for everyday treats, sharing with loved ones, or gifting just because.
Brown Butter Chocolate Chip
Soft-baked, brown buttery dough with golden edges, loaded with rich chocolate chips with hints of vanilla, espresso, and sea salt.
Half Dozen
$18
Full Dozen
$36

Oatmeal Creme Pies
Two soft oatmeal cookies sandwiched with fluffy spiced cream filling- nostalgic, comforting, crowd favorite with a twist
Half Dozen
$24
Full Dozen
$48

Baby In Bloom - Cookie Set
A dozen hand-decorated sugar cookies made with real butter and vanilla, perfect for celebrations, gifting, or a sweet little moment.
$54

Baby It's Cold Outside - Cookie Set
Hand-decorated sugar cookies made with real butter and vanilla, perfect for celebrations, gifting, or a sweet little moment.
$54

Soft Bakery Sugar Cookies
Soft, buttery sugar cookies topped with smooth buttercream icing. Simple, timeless, and bakery-classic with just the right touch of sweetness
Half Dozen
$18
Full Dozen
$36

Dark Chocolate Peppermint
Rich dark chocolate cookies with refreshing peppermint chips and sweet white chocolate chips folded throughout. Decadent, festive, and perfectly balanced.
Half Dozen
$18
Full Dozen
$36

Cookie Decorating Kits- Monthly Themed
A fun, hands-on cookie decorating experience featuring a rotating monthly theme. Each kit includes freshly baked sugar cookies, colorful icing, and festive toppings—perfect for family time, celebrations, or a creative sweet treat at home. Comes with Icing and Sprinkles
Half Dozen
$14
Full Dozen
$28
24 Pack
$55

My Person- Cookie Set
A cozy, love-filled cookie set made for the one who feels like home. Soft sugar cookies decorated in warm tones and simple designs—perfect for celebrating your favorite person, any day of the year.
Single serve
$4.50
Half Dozen
$27
Full Dozen
$54

Football Team - Cookie Set
A fun, game-day–ready sugar cookie set featuring classic football designs. Hand-decorated and fully customizable with team colors, names, or numbers—perfect for tailgates, watch parties, birthdays, and celebrations.
$54

Daddy's White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies
Soft brown butter cookies filled with creamy white chocolate chips and buttery macadamia nuts. Rich, nutty, and perfectly balanced with a tender bite.
Half Dozen
$18
Full Dozen
$36

Custom Hand Decorated Sugar Cookies
Soft, buttery sugar cookies hand-decorated with smooth royal icing. Fully customizable in design, colors, and themes—perfect for celebrations, events, and thoughtful gifting.
$54

Cookie Cakes
Our bakery-style cookie cakes are available in classic Oatmeal Cream, Sugar, and Chocolate Chip flavors. Choose from one or two layers, each soft, buttery, and baked to perfection—perfect for celebrations, or sharing with loved ones.
1 Layer
$40
2 Layers
$80
Cookie Flavors
Oatmeal
Sugar
Chocolate Chip


Cakes
Our cakes are baked fresh using quality ingredients and classic recipes, then finished with smooth buttercream and thoughtful details. Soft, flavorful, and made to celebrate everyday moments or life’s sweetest occasions.
Custom Cake- Deposit
A non-refundable deposit is required to secure your custom cake order and event date. This deposit will be applied toward the final balance and allows us to begin planning and designing your cake.
$25

Vintage Cakes
Inspired by classic bakery designs, our vintage cakes feature soft, tender layers finished with smooth buttercream, delicate piping, and timeless details. Romantic, nostalgic, and beautifully handcrafted, each cake feels like a sweet nod to the past—made to be celebrated today.
6 inch (serves up to 12)
$95
9 inch (serves up to 24)
$115
10 inch (serves up to 30)
$125
Flavors- Unless otherwise noted/added Cakes will be filled and decorated in Vanilla Buttercream.
Vanilla
Chocolate
Strawberry

Vintage Heart Cakes
Inspired by classic bakery designs, our vintage cakes feature soft, tender layers finished with smooth buttercream, delicate piping, and timeless details. Romantic, nostalgic, and beautifully handcrafted, each cake feels like a sweet nod to the past—made to be celebrated today.
6 inch (serves up to 12)
$95
9 inch (serves up to 24)
$115
Flavors- Unless otherwise noted/added Cakes will be filled and decorated in Vanilla Buttercream.
Vanilla
Chocolate
Strawberry

Bento Cake
A small, single-layer cake perfect for intimate celebrations or sweet little moments. Finished with smooth buttercream and simple, thoughtful details, our bento cakes are charming, personal, and just the right size to enjoy or share.
$30
Bento Flavors
Vanilla
Chocolate
Strawberry

Vanilla/Strawberry
Delicate layers of soft vanilla cake filled with homemade strawberry jam, made slow and rich with real fruit. Finished with smooth buttercream, this cake is anything but simple—balanced, nostalgic, and quietly indulgent, letting each ingredient shine.
6 inch (serves up to 12)
$70
9 inch (serves up to 24)
$85
10 inch (serves up to 30)
$100

Baby It's Cold Outside
Artisanal hand-made ravioli, filled with a blend of cheeses in a basil pesto sauce
6 inch (serves up to 12)
$95
9 inch (serves up to 24)
$115
10 inch (serves up to 30)
$130
Signs
Baby It's Cold Outside Sign
$5.99
Fantasy Garden Cake
A whimsical, storybook-inspired cake brought to life with soft sage buttercream, textured moss details, and delicate floral accents. Finished with a charming woodland door and fluttering butterflies, this cake feels like a secret garden straight out of a fairytale—perfect for weddings, baby showers, and anyone who believes in a little fantasy.
6 inch (serves up to 12)
$115
9 inch (serves up to 24)
$130
10 inch (serves up to 30)
$145

Rainbow Cake
Smooth, hand-blended buttercream finished in soft rainbow hues for a playful yet elegant look. Bright, joyful, and perfect for adding a pop of color to any cake or celebration.
6 inch (serves up to 12)
$85
9 inch (serves up to 24)
$100
10 inch (serves up to 30)
$115
Flavors- Unless otherwise noted/added Cakes will be filled and decorated in Vanilla Buttercream.
Vanilla
Chocolate
Strawberry

Baseball Cake
A playful, crowd-pleasing cake inspired by classic ballpark treats. Finished with caramel corn, crunchy pretzels, and smooth white chocolate spheres for the perfect mix of sweet and salty—this cake is a home run for special occassions and game-day celebrations
6 inch (serves up to 12)
$115
9 inch (serves up to 24)
$130
10 inch (serves up to 30)
$145
Flavors- Unless otherwise noted/added Cakes will be filled and decorated in Vanilla Buttercream.
Vanilla
Chocolate
Strawberry

Strawberry Cutie
A playful, strawberry-inspired cake reminiscent of the beloved Strawberry Shortcake doll. Finished with soft pink buttercream, strawberry details, and charming decorative touches, this cake feels sweet, nostalgic, and full of childhood magic—perfect for birthdays and joyful celebrations.
6 inch (serves up to 12)
$95
9 inch (serves up to 24)
$125
10 inch (serves up to 30)
$145
Flavors- Unless otherwise noted/added Cakes will be filled and decorated in Vanilla Buttercream.
Vanilla
Chocolate
Strawberry

Desserts
A rotating selection of bakery favorites including rich brownies, chocolate-dipped strawberries, soft donuts, and seasonal specialties like king cake. Thoughtfully made with quality ingredients, each dessert offers a little something extra sweet for every occasion.
Brown Butter Brownies
Fudgy, decadent brownies made with nutty brown butter for a deep, rich flavor and an irresistibly soft texture.
Single
$4
Half Dozen
$20
Full Dozen
$40

Chocolate Dipped Strawberries
Fresh, juicy strawberries hand-dipped in smooth, rich chocolate for a classic, indulgent treat—perfect for gifting, sharing, or savoring just because.
8 Pack
$20
Full Dozen
$28
2 Dozen
$40
Chocolate
Dark
Milk
White

King Cake
soft, tender cake with sweet cinnamon flavor, finished with a smooth glaze and festive sugar topping. Rich, comforting, and perfect for sharing, this traditional favorite brings a little celebration to every slice.
Small (Serves Up to 12)
$40
Medium (Serves up to 24)
$80
Large (Seves up to 36)
$120
Fillings
Cinnamon Sugar
Pecan Praline
$5Cream Cheese
$5